What does it mean to reason?
"What does the data show? Did the experiment work? Is the hypothesis correct?" Reasoning is the human process used to make sense of things. Reasoning is also used to establish and verify facts. Scientific reasoning is no different than everyday reasoning - it is used to make sense of things related to the scientific process, such as conclusions based on the results of an experiment.
Any useful hypothesis will allow predictions based on reasoning. Reasoning can be broken down into two categories: deduction and induction. Most reasoning in science is done through induction.
Deductive Reasoning: Deduction
Deduction involves determining a single fact from a general statement; it is only as accurate as the statement.
For example, if we know that all organisms are made of cells, need to maintain homeostasis and must reproduce to stay alive, and that humans are organisms, then humans are made of cells, maintain homeostasis and reproduce.
Deductions are intended to have reasoning that is valid. The reasoning in the following argument is valid, because there is no way in which the reasons 1 and 2, could be true and the conclusion, 3, be false:
- Reason 1: All humans are mortal.
- Reason 2: Albert Einstein is a human.
- Conclusion: Albert Einstein is mortal (Figure below).
Albert Einstein (1879–1955) Deductive reasoning has helped us determine that Albert Einstein is a mortal being.
Inductive Reasoning: Induction
Induction involves determining a general statement that is very likely to be true from several facts.
For example, if we have had a test every Tuesday for the past three months, we will have a test next Tuesday (and every Tuesday after that).
Induction contrasts strongly with deduction. Even in the best, or strongest, cases of induction, the truth of the reason does not guarantee the truth of the conclusion. Instead, the conclusion of an inductive argument is very likely to be true; you cannot be fully sure it is true because you are making a prediction that has yet to happen.
A classic example of inductive reasoning comes from the philosopher David Hume:
- Reason: The sun has risen in the east every morning up until now.
- Conclusion: The sun will also rise in the east tomorrow.
Inductive reasoning involves reaching conclusions about unobserved things on the basis of what has been observed already. Inferences about the past from present evidence, such as in archaeology, are induction. Induction could also be across outer space, as in astronomy, where conclusions about the whole universe are drawn from the limited number of things we are able to observe.
- deduction: Involves determining a single fact from a general statement.
- induction: Involves determining a general statement that is very likely to be true, from several facts; the relief of repression for a gene or set of genes under negative control.
- Any useful hypothesis will allow predictions based on reasoning. Reasoning can be broken down into two categories: deduction and induction. Most reasoning in science is formed through induction.
Use this resource to answer the questions that follow.
- INDUCTIVE AND DEDUCTIVE REASONING at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0OVCgruWDo.
- What is the difference between inductive and deductive reasoning?
- What is confirmation bias?
- Why did investors expect Shrek 3 to be a box office hit?
- What is meant by scientific reasoning?
- Outline the difference between inductive and deductive reasoning.