- State Democritus’s ideas about the atom.
- Outline Dalton’s atomic theory.
- Explain how Thomson discovered electrons.
- Describe how Rutherford found the nucleus.
Atoms are very tiny. They could not be seen before scanning tunneling microscopes were invented in 1981. However, the idea of atoms goes back to ancient Greece. That’s where this brief history of the atom begins. You can watch a video about the history of the atom at this URL: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6735732025674198539#.
Democritus Introduces the Atom
The history of the atom begins around 450 B.C. with a Greek philosopher named Democritus (see Figure below). Democritus wondered what would happen if you cut a piece of matter, such as an apple, into smaller and smaller pieces. He thought that a point would be reached where matter could not be cut into still smaller pieces. He called these "uncuttable" pieces atomos. This is where the modern term atom comes from.
Democritus first introduced the idea of the atom almost 2500 years ago.
Democritus was an important philosopher. However, he was less influential than the Greek philosopher Aristotle, who lived about 100 years after Democritus. Aristotle rejected Democritus’s idea of atoms. In fact, Aristotle thought the idea of atoms was ridiculous. Unfortunately, Aristotle’s ideas were accepted for more than 2000 years. During that time, Democritus’s ideas were more or less forgotten.
Dalton Brings Back the Atom
Around 1800, a British chemist named John Dalton revived Democritus’s early ideas about the atom. Dalton is pictured in Figure below. He made a living by teaching and just did research in his spare time. Nonetheless, from his research results, he developed one of the most important theories in science.
John Dalton used evidence from experiments to show that atoms exist.
Dalton did many experiments that provided evidence for atoms. For example, he studied the pressure of gases. He concluded that gases must consist of tiny particles in constant motion. Dalton also researched the properties of compounds. He showed that a compound always consists of the same elements in the same ratio. On the other hand, different compounds always consist of different elements or ratios. This can happen, Dalton reasoned, only if elements are made of tiny particles that can combine in an endless variety of ways. From his research, Dalton developed a theory of the atom. You can learn more about Dalton and his research by watching the video at this URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhWgv0STLZs&feature=related (9:03).
Dalton's Atomic Theory
The atomic theory Dalton developed consists of three ideas:
- All substances are made of atoms. Atoms are the smallest particles of matter. They cannot be divided into smaller particles. They also cannot be created or destroyed.
- All atoms of the same element are alike and have the same mass. Atoms of different elements are different and have different masses.
- Atoms join together to form compounds. A given compound always consists of the same kinds of atoms in the same ratio.
Dalton’s theory was soon widely accepted. Most of it is still accepted today. The only part that is no longer accepted is his idea that atoms are the smallest particles. Scientists now know that atoms consist of even smaller particles.
Dalton's Atomic Models
Dalton incorrectly thought that atoms are tiny solid particles of matter. He used solid wooden balls to model them. The sketch below (Figure below) shows how Dalton’s model atoms looked. He made holes in the balls so they could be joined together with hooks. In this way, the balls could be used to model compounds. When later scientists discovered subatomic particles (particles smaller than the atom itself), they realized that Dalton’s models were too simple. They didn’t show that atoms consist of even smaller particles. Models including these smaller particles were later developed.
Dalton’s model atoms were hard, solid balls. How do they differ from the atomic models you saw in the lesson "Inside the Atom" from earlier in the chapter?
Thomson Adds Electrons
The next major advance in the history of the atom was the discovery of electrons. These were the first subatomic particles to be identified. They were discovered in 1897 by a British physicist named J. J. Thomson. You can learn more about Thomson and his discovery at this online exhibit: http://www.aip.org/history/electron/.
Thomson's Vacuum Tube Experiments
Thomson was interested in electricity. He did experiments in which he passed an electric current through a vacuum tube. The experiments are described in Figure below.
This sketch shows the basic set up of Thomson’s experiments. The vacuum tube is a glass tube that contains very little air. It has metal plates at each end and along the sides.
Thomson’s experiments showed that an electric current consists of flowing, negatively charged particles. Why was this discovery important? Many scientists of Thomson’s time thought that electric current consists of rays, like rays of light, and that it is positive rather than negative. Thomson’s experiments also showed that the negative particles are all alike and smaller than atoms. Thomson concluded that the negative particles couldn’t be fundamental units of matter because they are all alike. Instead, they must be parts of atoms. The negative particles were later named electrons.
Thomson's Plum Pudding Model
Thomson knew that atoms are neutral in electric charge. So how could atoms contain negative particles? Thomson thought that the rest of the atom must be positive to cancel out the negative charge. He said that an atom is like a plum pudding, which has plums scattered through it. That’s why Thomson’s model of the atom is called the plum pudding model. You can see it in Figure below. It shows the atom as a sphere of positive charge (the pudding) with negative electrons (the plums) scattered through it.
Thomson’s atomic model includes negative electrons in a "sea" of positive charge.
Rutherford Finds the Nucleus
A physicist from New Zealand named Ernest Rutherford made the next major discovery about atoms. He discovered the nucleus. You can watch a video about Rutherford and his discovery at this URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wzALbzTdnc8 (3:28).
Rutherford's Gold Foil Experiments
In 1899, Rutherford discovered that some elements give off positively charged particles. He named them alpha particles (α). In 1911, he used alpha particles to study atoms. He aimed a beam of alpha particles at a very thin sheet of gold foil. Outside the foil, he placed a screen of material that glowed when alpha particles struck it.
Rutherford shot a beam of positive alpha particles at thin gold foil.
If Thomson’s plum pudding model were correct, the alpha particles should be deflected a little as they passed through the foil. Why? The positive "pudding" part of gold atoms would slightly repel the positive alpha particles. This would cause the alpha particles to change course. But Rutherford got a surprise. Most of the alpha particles passed straight through the foil as though they were moving through empty space. Even more surprising, a few of the alpha particles bounced back from the foil as though they had struck a wall. This is called back scattering. It happened only in very small areas at the centers of the gold atoms.
The Nucleus and Its Particles
Based on his results, Rutherford concluded that all the positive charge of an atom is concentrated in a small central area. He called this area the nucleus. Rutherford later discovered that the nucleus contains positively charged particles. He named the positive particles protons. Rutherford also predicted the existence of neutrons in the nucleus. However, he failed to find them. One of his students, a physicist named James Chadwick, went on to discover neutrons in 1932. You learn how at this URL: http://www.light-science.com/chadwick.html.
Rutherford's Atomic Model
Rutherford’s discoveries meant that Thomson’s plum pudding model was incorrect. Positive charge is not spread out everywhere in an atom. It is all concentrated in the tiny nucleus. The rest of the atom is empty space, except for the electrons moving randomly through it. In Rutherford’s model, electrons move around the nucleus in random orbits. He compared them to planets orbiting a star. That’s why Rutherford’s model is called the planetary model. You can see it in Figure below.
This model shows Rutherford’s idea of the atom. How does it compare with Thomson’s plum pudding model?
- Around 450 B.C., the Greek philosopher Democritus introduced the idea of the atom. However, the idea was essentially forgotten for more than 2000 years.
- In 1800, John Dalton re-introduced the atom. He provided evidence for atoms and developed atomic theory. His theory is essentially correct. However, he incorrectly thought that atoms are the smallest particles of matter.
- In 1897, J.J. Thomson discovered electrons. He proposed the plum pudding model of the atom. In this model, negative electrons are scattered throughout a "sea" of positive charge.
- In 1911, Ernest Rutherford discovered the nucleus. He later discovered protons as well. Rutherford thought that electrons randomly orbit the nucleus.
Lesson Review Questions
- State Democritus’s ideas about the atom.
- What evidence did Dalton use to argue for the existence of atoms?
- State Dalton’s atomic theory.
- Describe how Thomson discovered electrons.
- Create sketches to compare and contrast Thomson’s and Rutherford’s models of the atom.
- Based on Rutherford’s work, use evidence and reasoning to argue for the existence of the nucleus.
Points to Consider
In this lesson, you read how models of the atom changed as scientists discovered the particles that make up atoms. In the next lesson, "Modern Atomic Theory," you will read how Rutherford’s model was revised as scientists learned even more about electrons. For example, they discovered that electrons do not travel around the nucleus in random orbits as Rutherford thought.
- Can you predict how electrons might move around the nucleus?
- How might Rutherford’s model be changed to show this?